Index Funds vs Active Funds in India: A 10-Year SIP Comparison

Every few months someone asks the same question in a family WhatsApp group: should I put my SIP in an index fund, or in a fund with a manager who is trying to beat the market?

It is a good question, and it has a surprisingly clear answer once you look at two things together: what the costs do to your money over ten years, and how often active funds have actually beaten their benchmarks.

This article works through both with ₹10,000 a month. The returns used in the worked example are assumptions for illustration, not forecasts and not the record of any real fund. The track-record figures come from S&P Dow Jones Indices’ SPIVA India Scorecard.

What an index fund is, and what an active fund is

An index fund buys every stock in an index, such as the Nifty 50 or the Sensex, in the same proportions as the index. Nobody decides which stocks to buy. The fund’s job is to match the index as closely as possible, minus its costs. The small gap between the fund’s return and the index’s return is called tracking difference.

An active fund has a fund manager and a research team who pick stocks they believe will do better than the market. The fund is measured against a benchmark index. If the manager picks well, the fund beats the benchmark. If not, it lags.

Both are mutual funds. Both can be bought through a SIP. Both carry full equity risk: if the market falls 30%, an index fund falls about 30% too, and an active fund may fall more or less.

The one number that is certain: cost

Every mutual fund charges an annual fee called the total expense ratio, or TER. It is taken out of the fund’s assets every day, so you never see a bill. You only see a slightly lower return.

Index funds are cheap to run because there is no stock-picking team. Active funds cost more. SEBI caps the expense ratio a fund may charge, and the cap for index funds and ETFs has been far lower than the cap for actively managed equity funds (under the 2020 slabs published by AMFI, 1% against up to 2.25%; SEBI revised the framework again in December 2025).

There is a second cost layer. Since January 2013, every mutual fund scheme has had to offer a direct plan alongside the regular plan, under a SEBI circular of September 2012. The direct plan has a lower expense ratio because no distributor commission is paid out of it. Same fund, same portfolio, different cost.

To keep the example simple, we use three illustrative cost levels:

Type of fundIllustrative yearly cost (assumption)
Index fund0.2%
Active fund, direct plan0.8%
Active fund, regular plan1.6%

These are round numbers for illustration. Check the actual TER of any fund on its factsheet or the AMC website before you compare.

The worked example: ₹10,000 a month for 10 years

Assume the market — the index itself — returns 12% a year for ten years. That is an assumption, not a forecast. Equity returns vary widely and can be negative for several years in a row.

Now assume the active fund’s manager exactly matches the market before costs. The only difference between the funds is what they charge.

You invest ₹10,000 at the start of every month for 120 months. Total invested: ₹12 lakh.

FundReturn after costs (assumed)Value after 10 years
Index fund11.8%about ₹22.96 lakh
Active fund, direct plan11.2%about ₹22.16 lakh
Active fund, regular plan10.4%about ₹21.14 lakh

The gap between the cheapest and the most expensive option is about ₹1.8 lakh on ₹12 lakh invested. That is money the market earned for you and the costs took away. Over 20 or 25 years, the same gap grows much larger, because the lost returns stop compounding for you.

You can run your own numbers in our SIP calculator. Try your SIP amount at two rates 1% apart and see the difference.

But a good active fund can beat the market

True. That is the whole case for active funds. A manager who beats the market by enough to cover the extra cost, and then some, leaves you better off than an index fund.

So let us widen the example. Same ₹10,000 a month for ten years, same 12% market:

Outcome (all returns are assumptions)Return after costsValue after 10 years
Active fund beats the market by 0.8% after its costs12.8%about ₹24.37 lakh
Index fund11.8%about ₹22.96 lakh
Active fund lags the market by 2.2% after its costs9.8%about ₹20.42 lakh

Picking a winner adds about ₹1.4 lakh. Picking a laggard costs about ₹2.5 lakh. The question is not whether winners exist. It is how often they show up, and whether you can find them in advance.

What the record says: SPIVA India

S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes the SPIVA India Scorecard, which counts how many active funds in each category did worse than their benchmark. Its Year-End 2025 edition covers periods ending 31 December 2025. The fund returns it uses are net of fees, excluding loads.

Category (SPIVA benchmark)Share of active funds that underperformed over 10 years
Indian Equity Large-Cap (S&P India LargeMidCap)76.3%
Indian ELSS (S&P India BMI)82.9%
Indian Equity Mid-/Small-Cap (S&P India SmallCap)79.0%

Three in four large-cap active funds lagged their benchmark over the decade. The same report shows that only about 79% of the large-cap funds that existed at the start of the ten years were still around at the end; the rest were merged or closed, which tends to hide weak records.

Two honest caveats. First, one year can look very different: in calendar 2025, only about 12% of mid- and small-cap active funds underperformed their benchmark. Shorter periods move around a lot. Second, SPIVA compares funds with an S&P index, not with a real index fund you could buy, and an index fund also has costs and tracking difference. The scorecard tells you about the odds, not about any single fund.

So which one should you use?

That depends on you, and this article cannot decide it for you. But the evidence suggests a few practical principles.

Start with cost. Whatever you choose, know the expense ratio you are paying and whether you are in a direct or regular plan. On a ₹10,000 SIP, a 1% yearly difference is worth more than a lakh over ten years.

For large-cap exposure, many investors use an index fund as the core, because the large-cap record above makes beating the index after costs hard. Some then add active funds in areas where they believe a manager can add value, and accept the risk that they may not.

If you choose an active fund, judge it against its benchmark over five to ten years, not one good year. A fund that has lagged its benchmark for years is giving you the market’s risk without the market’s return.

Whatever you choose, the bigger levers are the boring ones: the amount you invest, how long you stay invested, and raising the SIP as your income rises. Those matter more than the index-versus-active choice.

Your one action this week

Open your mutual fund statement. For each equity fund, write down three things: whether it is an index fund or active, its expense ratio, and whether it is a direct or regular plan. For each active fund, look up how it has done against its benchmark over five years. That list will tell you more than any ranking.

Every Monday, Finostock Money Letter takes one money decision and works it through with real numbers. It is free and takes about five minutes to read. Subscribe here.

Educational content only — not investment, tax, or legal advice. Finostock provides general personal-finance education and information. We are not SEBI-registered investment advisers and do not recommend any fund or scheme. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks; read all scheme-related documents carefully. Returns in the worked examples are assumptions for illustration; past performance does not guarantee future results.

Leave a Reply